“The Precarious State of the Monarch Butterfly”

Hi, I’m John Rafferty, I am the editor for Earth Sciences at Encyclopaedia Britannica, and today we are exploring the conservation status of the Monarch Butterfly—perhaps most well-known butterfly species in the world.

The monarch is known for its ability to take the chemicals from its food source, milkweed, and make itself distasteful to birds and other predators—so much so that other species of butterflies evolve to copy the Monarch’s appearance—and its spectacular long-distance migration from central Mexico through North America.
Spend some time with us, and we’ll explore the monarch’s natural history, the threats posed to the species by habitat loss and pesticides, and some encouraging signs about the Monarch’s recovery in the eastern United States.

And don’t worry, if you miss something during this talk, you can find it again our website.

Let’s get down to the science.

The Monarch butterfly, (Danaus plexippus), is a familiar member of the milkweed butterfly. This butterfly is known for its large size, its orange and black wings, and its long annual migrations. Monarchs are concentrated in North, Central, and South America but can also be found in Australia, Hawaii, India, and other locations. Several subspecies of monarchs have been recognized. The subspecies Danaus plexippus plexippus is a migratory monarch found primarily in North America.
In this podcast, we will consider two of North America’s populations of monarchs: the eastern North American population, which accounts for the overwhelming majority of North American monarchs that overwinters in Mexico’s oyamel fir forests (in a mountainous region northwest of Mexico City). The other group, the western population, overwinters in California.

The monarch’s wingspan averages 90 to 100 mm (about 4 inches). The coloration of the orange wings, marked by black veins and a black border with two rows of spots, warns predators of the insect’s bad taste. The viceroy butterfly and the monarch share similar coloration. And, like the monarch, the viceroy is unpalatable to some of its predators. Hence, it is believed that the two species resemblance is a form of defense against predators.

In North America thousands of monarchs gather in autumn and migrate southward, sometimes traveling almost 3,000 km (about 1,800 miles) between their summer and winter habitats. The monarchs return north in the spring, feeding on nectar along the way. Eggs are laid only on milkweed plants, and a new generation hatches, matures, and continues the northward trip.
These butterflies are important pollinators in the ecosystems that they inhabit, moving pollen as they bounce from plant to plant in search of nectar. In addition, Monarch caterpillars feast on the milkweed—in fact, they dine on it exclusively. The success of the population depends the maximizing the number of caterpillars that mature to become adults, which, ultimately depends upon milkweed availability. Without adequate milkweed, the caterpillars would starve, and population losses at this early stage of development would mean that there would be fewer adults breeding (and thus fewer caterpillars) the following year.

Caterpillars take in the plant’s toxins and this changes their body chemistry, and they become distasteful to most predators—but other insects, such as wasps, flies, and ants—as well as some spiders are able to stomach them. In addition, fully-grown monarchs in their overwintering grounds are not protected from grosbeaks and orioles.

BUT IN RECENT DECADES, THE MONARCH POPULATION HAS BEGUN TO DECLINE.

Since the mid-1990s, monarch habitat in Mexico’s oyamel fir forests have declined from 21 hectares to less than a single hectare in 2014. This is concerning because ecologists estimate that the Monarch requires at least six hectares of overwintering habitat to sustain its population.
Likewise, the western population has plummeted from an estimated 10 million butterflies in the 1980s to about 1.2 million butterflies around the Year 2000 to only about 30,000 in 2019.

In both cases, scientists are worried about the long-term survival of these populations, with one recent study conducted by ecologists from Washington State University and the Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation stating that the western population has a greater than even chance of dying out in 20 years and an 84-percent chance of dying out in 50 years.
The eastern population, while still in peril, seems to be recovering slightly—in part due to the efforts of citizen scientists and gardeners who have protected and planted milkweed in their backyards and public spaces. The period 2018-2019 saw the highest population in a decade and noted that monarchs of the eastern population inhabited just over 6 hectares of critical overwintering habitat in Mexico.

SO, WHAT IS CAUSING THEIR POPULATIONS TO DECREASE?

A mix of agricultural changes and climate changes are contributing to the declines of both populations.

The overwintering habitat of both populations is decreasing. In California, current habitat loss is coming from drought and wildfire damage—California is still recovering from a decade-long drought—and possibly from a period of unusually heavy rains during the winter of 2017-2018.
In Mexico, despite the establishment of the 56,000-hectare Monarch Biosphere Reserve in 2008 to protect the oyamel fir forest, some illegal logging does take place cutting into the butterfly’s habitat. More perniciously, however, climate change in Mexico is likely to alter the oyamel forest, and some ecologists are developing plans to help the forest migrate (with long-term reforestation) to support the trees and the butterflies that inhabit them.
Summer habitat and habitat along migratory routes, mainly patches of milkweed and other wildflowers, have declined in recent years due to expanded agriculture—and more importantly—the expanded use of pesticides and herbicides (which kill milkweed, wildflowers, and multiple species of insects (including monarch caterpillars and adults). This includes the controversial neonicotinoid insecticides.

In the early 21st century, some researchers suspected that a loss of milkweed plants was associated with the expanded use of genetically modified crops in the United States. This has further placed the monarch’s long-term survival in jeopardy.

SO, WHAT CAN WE DO?

Since overwintering habitat is critical to the butterfly’s survival, pressuring local and national leaders to conserve and expand important landscapes and habitats will help in the short term.

Over the long term, however, this may not be enough, since changing climates are also putting pressure on critical habitats. So, as with many species throughout this podcast series, fighting climate change should be among the top conservation priorities.

Locally, however, there is still a lot that you and I can do. Since monarch caterpillars depend on milkweed for their food, protecting standing patches of milkweed in your area—even to the point of planting milkweed in your backyard or community gardens—can help a great deal.

You can also plant more nectar-producing plants. Black-eyed Susans, New England Asters, and goldenrod are some of the many plants can provide nectar to monarchs in the Upper Midwest, where I’m from. The right plant species will differ depending on the region you live in and the season.

Check with conservation groups and local government offices in your area to find out which plants would be the best for monarchs. Here are three milkweed species to consider:
The showy milkweed [Asclepais speciose] appears over large parts of the western United States across a broad range of moisture conditions
The swamp milkweed [Asclepais incarnata] casts a wide net from Nevada and Idaho in the west to Quebec, Nova Scotia, and Florida in the east.

The common milkweed [Asclepais syriaca] is found in Oregon and Montana in the west and from the Great Plains through the eastern US to Quebec and Nova Scotia.

The Monarch butterfly in North America is in trouble, but it is not lost—at least not yet—and there are encouraging signs that one population is improving. Although the problems of regulating climate change and agriculture remain tough to crack, there is still much you and I can do to keep monarchs and the plants that sustain them alive until solutions to these larger problems emerge.

Thanks for taking the time to listen today, and I hope you learned something new about one of the world’s most stately and recognizable butterflies. Most importantly, I hope that you learned about the current state of North American monarch conservation and what we must do to ensure that they last throughout the 21st century and beyond.
Don’t forget, you can catch up on anything you might have missed on Britannica.com. Learn more about extinction and its causes from our article located at 64.176.36.150/science/extinction-biology.

There you can also find other parts of this podcast series.

More information on the Monarch butterfly, pesticides, climate change, and pollination can be found at 64.176.36.150.

The Precarious State Of The Monarch Butterfly. Story by: John Rafferty. Produced by: Kurt Heintz. This is the fourth part of the “Postcards from the 6th Mass Extinction” series.
This program is copyrighted by Encyclopaedia Britannica Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.